Explaining Tottenham’s complex racism case – The Athletic FC

26 September 2024Last Update :
Explaining Tottenham’s complex racism case – The Athletic FC

The Athletic FC ⚽ is The Athletic’s daily football (or soccer, if you prefer) newsletter. Sign up to receive it directly to your inbox.


Hello. Today, we’re writing about an emotional Son Heung-min press conference. He’s clearly forgiven Rodrigo Bentancur.

Coming up:

  • What next for Tottenham?
  • Arsenal’s teenage ninja turtles
  • Woeful Man United defending
  • Brentford’s not-so-sneak attacks

Son shows compassion but Bentancur faces ban

In June, Tottenham Hotspur midfielder Rodrigo Bentancur gave an interview to a television station in his home country of Uruguay, the type of chat that tends to pass the world by — and but for one remark, it would have done.

During the interview, Bentancur made a racial slur in jest about his Tottenham team-mate and captain, the South Korea international Son Heung-min. Word about it spread and Bentancur quickly said sorry, describing it as “a joke in bad taste”. Son accepted his apology and said, “We’re past it.”

In an official statement, Spurs said they “fully support that our captain Sonny feels that he can draw a line under the incident”, but a fortnight ago, Bentancur was charged by the Football Association over the remark. It is yet to be confirmed if the 27-year-old has pleaded guilty or not guilty.

The FA considered Bentancur’s alleged breach to be aggravated because it related to “nationality and/or race and/or ethnic origin”. In layman’s terms, any punishment stands to be more severe than it would be for a standard breach. If found guilty, or if he accepts the charge, Bentancur faces a ban of six to 12 matches.

Son had previously gone public about Bentancur’s interview, but yesterday, he gave his reaction to the FA’s charge — the first time he has taken direct questions concerning the controversy. Once again, he spoke with remarkable compassion.

Rodrigo Bentancur, Son Heung-min and the FA charge hanging over Tottenham

‘I repeat: I love him, I love him’

This is a highly unusual scenario. What we have is two big Premier League personalities in the same dressing room who have succeeded in patching things up — but not in averting disciplinary proceedings.

Son spoke to the media at a press conference before Tottenham’s opening Europa League tie against Azerbaijan’s Qarabag tonight. The Athletic’s Jay Harris asked him to reflect on Bentancur and the FA charge.

“I repeat: I love him, I love him,” said Son. “He almost cried when he apologised publicly, and also personally as well. It felt like he feels really sorry.”

Son took care not to comment on whether FA action was justified. Irrespective of Bentancur’s contrition, the governing body could take the view that a potential breach of its rules is the same as any other — and that excusing his comments without due process would reflect poorly on its approach to alleged racism or bigotry.

I asked Jay what he made of Son’s demeanour in the press conference. “His answer made a big impact on everyone in the room,” Jay told me. “It’s the first time we’ve heard Son’s side of the story. Bentancur could be banned for nearly a third of the season, but the most important thing is that he educates himself. Son’s comments suggest that process is underway.”

What does this mean for Spurs?

It would be wrong to reduce this situation to football alone, but a long suspension for Bentancur would leave head coach Ange Postecoglou short on midfield options. Jay has been reflecting on whether the club possess the resources to progress in both the Premier League and Europe.

For now, we await the outcome of Bentancur’s case. Whatever the consequences, he, Son and Tottenham will be relieved when they can put this episode behind them.


News Round-Up 🗞️

How Madrid could replace Mbappe
  • Getafe’s Nigerian midfielder Christantus Uche has voiced complaints about racism and his treatment from referees in Spain. Unbelievably, his own club’s president, Angel Torres, has criticised Uche for speaking out: “From now on, what he’ll have to do is not speak.” Wow.
  • Kylian Mbappe is out for three weeks with a thigh injury, so will miss Sunday’s derby between his Real Madrid side and neighbours Atletico. Real will go through hell and high water to get him back for El Clasico against Barcelona on October 26.
  • A group of Lazio fans were shut out of their Europa League clash with Dynamo Kyiv yesterday after local police confiscated weapons from some of them. The items seized included knives, a club and several meat pounders. We’re assuming they weren’t planning to cook steak.
  • The venues for the 2025 Gold Cup have been announced. All 14 are in the United States and Canada. CONCACAF has gone heavy on the west coast.

Arsenal’s Nursery 👶

Manchester City and Arsenal just cannot help going head to head. City field a 16-year-old, their third-youngest starter ever, in the Carabao Cup on Tuesday, so Arsenal do likewise 24 hours later. Jack Porter, a baby-faced goalkeeper, is the second-youngest debutant in Arsenal’s history.

It was a 17-year-old, though, who hogged the limelight during their 5-1 third-round win over Bolton Wanderers of League One last night. Midfielder Ethan Nwaneri made his first senior start and scored twice. He’s going to be good. Porter, in for the mildly injured David Raya, got through the evening without major mishaps — unlike counterpart Isak Pettersson in Elfsborg’s 3-2 Europa League defeat to AZ Alkmaar (below).

Lepers, rat-stabbers and cheese heads: The origins of football team nicknames from around the world
(TNT Sports)

I don’t know what I like more about this blunder — Pettersson spilling the catch with nobody around him, or him brashly attempting to blame someone else. Nice try.

And then we had Manchester United being Manchester United. Will Erik ten Hag ever get it together?

Twente’s equaliser (below) in a Europa League draw at Old Trafford wasn’t far off making the list of the worst goals ever conceded: a buccaneering run from right-back, a misplaced clearance and a cheap finish at the near post. Concessions don’t get much more defensively inept.

Man United 1 Twente 1 – Eriksen scores, Rashford shines, but so many errors led to Twente’s goal
(TNT Sports)

Ten Hag had a pop at United’s mentality afterwards, accusing his players of being “too easygoing” at 1-0 up. “They (Twente) fought for every yard and we didn’t,” he said. He wasn’t wrong, but it begs the question asked of Ten Hag so many times already: whose job is it to address that?


Brentford’s Fast Starts ⚡

Looking at the table five games into the Premier League season, something jumps out immediately: the six clubs at the bottom without a single win to their names.

That hasn’t happened in England’s top flight before and the biggest surprise is Wolverhampton Wanderers festering in 20th (aka, last) place. In fairness to head coach Gary O’Neil, he had them ready to go — but they’ve committed a false start. They’ll be clinging to the fact their initial set of fixtures were tough.

But my favourite trend is Brentford’s approach to kick-offs. The west Londoners love an early-doors ambush, scoring after 22 seconds at Manchester City and 23 seconds at Spurs on successive weekends. Those were the division’s fastest back-to-back goals.

Five tactical takeaways from the Premier League’s first five weekends

Brentford are renowned for set-piece planning and our Mark Carey has been studying the way they use the kick-off. There’s a distinct formula: Mikkel Damsgaard passing back to goalkeeper Mark Flekken, Flekken sending a long diagonal to 6ft 6in (198cm) defender Kristoffer Ajer, and Brentford trying to pounce on the second ball from his flick.

Look out for more of the same at West Ham United this weekend. They need a talking-to if they fall for it.


Around The Athletic FC 🌎

MADRID, SPAIN - MAY 08: Florentino Perez, President of Real Madrid (L), interacts with Carlo Ancelotti, Head Coach of Real Madrid, (R) after the UEFA Champions League semi-final second leg match between Real Madrid and FC Bayern München at Estadio Santiago Bernabeu on May 08, 2024 in Madrid, Spain. (Photo by Angel Martinez - UEFA/UEFA via Getty Images)
  • Carlo Ancelotti has gone past 300 games in charge of Real Madrid (admittedly in two separate spells). A job so big can eat a manager, but not him. Dermot Corrigan went in search of the secrets of Ancelotti’s survival.
  • Two new Premier League bosses are under the cosh. Steve Cooper got the bird from Leicester City’s fans on Tuesday and West Ham took a pasting from Liverpool in the Carabao Cup yesterday. Julen Lopetegui needs respite, fast.
  • Not so Liverpool head coach Arne Slot. His attacking corps are on fire.
  • Arsenal’s swagger is alive and well and their next three league fixtures (Leicester, Southampton and Bournemouth) look tasty. Holly Shand’s Fantasy Premier League tip is to bet the house on Bukayo Saka. I’m in.
  • Most clicked in yesterday’s TAFC: Barcelona’s Camp Nou reconstruction — will they really be back this year?

Catch A Match (Times ET/UK) 📡

Europa League: Fenerbahce vs Union Saint-Gilloise, 12.45pm/5.45pm — Paramount+/TNT SportsMalmo vs Rangers, 12.45pm/5.45pm — CBS, Paramount+Fubo/TNT SportsAjax vs Besiktas 3pm/8pm — Paramount+, Vix/TNT SportsTottenham Hotspur vs Qarabag, 3pm/8pm — Paramount+, Vix/TNT Sports; Roma vs Athletic Bilbao, 3pm/8pm — CBS Sports, Paramount+, Fubo/TNT Sports.

La Liga: Celta Vigo vs Atletico Madrid, 3pm/8pm — ESPN+, Fubo/Premier Sports.

(Top photo: Sebastian Frej/MB Media/Getty Images)